, , ,

Agency Referrals Now Happen in a Chat Window

Referrals for your agency typically work this way: a marketer has a need, asks someone she trusted who to call, and that person remembered your firm well enough to say your name along with a sentence about what you do.

For many (most?) firms, this process has been reliable enough that it is their business development strategy.

This year, the numbers make it hard to ignore how this is changing for agencies.

In our 2026 Agency New Business Report,

44% of agency leaders said referrals are working for them as a source of new business, down from 76% a year earlier.

More than half (54%) said referral business has slowed, and only 4% said it increased.

One explanation is certainly that the market is tougher, but if you break a referral down to its parts, a more useful answer emerges.

What does a referral actually require?

A referral only happens when four things line up:

  1. A buyer decides to ask someone for a recommendation.
  2. The person they ask is someone they trust.
  3. That person remembers your agency.
  4. They can describe you clearly enough that the buyer follows up.

Remove any one of these pieces and the referral won’t happen, and the first two appear to be changing fastest.

Are marketers still tapping into their network?

Less than they used to.

Our New Year Outlook research looks at the same question from the client side of the table, and the shift is striking.

In 2022, 73% of clients said they learned about new firms through networking, 67% through past relationships, and 60% through friends or co-workers.

By 2025, only 58% of clients cited networking, 48% past relationships, and 35% friends or co-workers.

That’s nearly a 25-point drop in marketers turning to friends and co-workers, the most personal referral source there is.

Add consolidation, with fewer marketers moving between companies and bringing their agencies along, and the first link in the chain is noticeably weaker.

Who are your prospects asking instead?

Increasingly, a chat window.

In a survey of 350 business buyers by Responsive, 90% of buyers said they conduct research before first contact, often forming a clear view of preferred vendors early in the process.

About one-third cited web search, peer recommendations, and generative AI chatbots as their primary ways of finding new vendors, and two-thirds said they now use generative AI tools as much as, or more than, traditional search engines.

Forrester’s research goes further, with AI usage among business buyers at 94%, up from 89% a year earlier.

In other words, AI tools are now on equal footing with the trusted colleague as a place buyers go for a recommendation.

The difference is that an AI tool has never worked with you, it only knows what’s been written about you.

Referrals happen in rooms you aren’t in, and today, that room is increasingly a chat window.

Agency Referrals Now Happen in a Chat Window

Can your agency pass the AI referral test?

Here’s a five-minute exercise worth doing.

Test and ask the following questions across multiple AI platforms (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude,  and Gemini, for example):

  • “Who are the best agencies for [your specialty] for [your type of client]?”
  • “What is [your agency name] known for?”

One of these will happen:

  1. You’re named and described accurately
  2. You’re named, but described in generic terms that could fit a hundred other firms.
  3. You’re not named at all.

In our experience, most agencies land in the second or third group, and that points to the fourth link in the chain.

If an AI tool can’t describe your agency in a sentence, there’s a good chance your best client can’t either. (Our recent positioning research found most agencies believe they’re differentiated while describing the industry as undifferentiated, and that’s a topic for another post.)

How do you become easy to recommend?

Give them something specific to repeat.

Write your one sentence. Spell out who you’re best for and what you do better than anyone else. Then ask a happy client to describe your agency in their own words and compare the two.

Put that sentence everywhere the new referrer reads. Your website, LinkedIn page, case studies, team bios, and directory listings should all tell the same story. AI tools can only repeat what they can find, and a scattered message gets repeated as a vague one.

Earn mentions beyond your own site. Press coverage, podcast appearances, awards, guest articles, and client quotes on partner sites are the digital version of a colleague vouching for you. They give both people and AI tools a reason to say your name.

Keep your human referrers stocked. When a project goes well, tell the client in plain words what kind of work you’d love to do more of. People recommend what they can explain, so make it easy for them.

Should you still count on referrals?

Absolutely, but treat them as one source among several.

Our survey report shows agencies are already leaning harder on the relationships they know best: 52% now cite existing clients as a working source of new business, up from 27%, and networking rose from 34% to 40%.

And for the prospects who have never heard of you, nothing replaces reaching out directly.

I cover the easiest places to start in Agency Outbound Prospecting: Stop Ignoring the 3 Easiest Methods Right in Front of You.

Referrals are about being easy to recommend by whoever’s doing the recommending.

That job used to belong only to your clients and colleagues but now it’s shared with tools that have never met you and only know what you’ve published.

The full findings are in our 2026 Agency New Business Report.

And if you’d like a second set of eyes on how your agency comes across to prospects, we’re always happy to take a look.